Hollywood Studios Push Back on AI Copyright Legislation


In the rapidly evolving world of artificial intelligence (AI), Hollywood studios are making their stance clear on the issue of copyright. Amidst the growing discussions in Washington D.C. about establishing guidelines for AI, major film studios are cautioning against the implementation of rigid rules, emphasizing that the current copyright laws are adequate to address the challenges posed by emerging AI technologies.

Key Takeaways:

  • Major studios believe existing copyright laws are sufficient for AI challenges.
  • Studios’ views on AI were detailed in a Motion Picture Association (MPA) filing with the U.S. Copyright Office.
  • The MPA’s legal team asserts that AI technologies, while novel, still fall under well-established copyright doctrines.
  • The MPA opposes the need for new legislation or special rules for AI in the context of copyright.
  • Studios emphasize that AI can enhance human creativity without replacing it.
  • President Joe Biden’s recent executive order on AI did not touch on copyright issues.
  • The MPA has reservations about the proposed No Fakes Act and other ideas that might limit artistic freedom.

The Motion Picture Association (MPA) recently filed a document with the U.S. Copyright Office, outlining the studios’ collective position on a range of AI-related issues. The filing, which was authored by the MPA’s legal team, including Karyn Temple, Benjamin Sheffner, and Terrica Carrington, highlighted the studios’ belief that while AI does present new questions, these queries are still rooted in long-standing copyright principles.

The MPA’s stance is that there’s no immediate need for new legislation or special rules to apply copyright law in the AI context. They argue that developments in AI, much like previous technological advancements, have the potential to augment, not replace, human creativity. The association’s members are confident that these AI advancements can coexist harmoniously with a copyright system that both incentivizes original expression and safeguards the rights of copyright holders.

Interestingly, President Joe Biden recently issued an executive order addressing various concerns about AI. One of the provisions in this order aims to establish standards for watermarking AI-generated content, primarily to identify “deepfakes.” However, this order did not delve into the realm of copyright, leaving that arena for Congress to tackle.

The Senate Majority Leader, Chuck Schumer, has been actively working on AI legislation. Additionally, other lawmakers have proposed draft bills concerning the unauthorized use of a performer’s digital likeness. However, there’s already a divergence in opinions regarding the specifics.

Earlier this year, the Copyright Office released guidance on AI, stating that only content created by humans can be protected by copyright. This guidance also emphasized the duty of copyright applicants to disclose any AI-generated content in their submissions. The MPA’s filing took issue with this stance, suggesting that the Copyright Office hasn’t adequately differentiated between various AI applications.

Furthermore, the MPA’s document touched upon the use of copyrighted material in AI training models. Several authors, including renowned names like John Grisham and George R.R. Martin, have initiated lawsuits against companies like OpenAI and Meta for using their works in AI training models. The MPA believes that potential infringement cases should be dealt with based on the “fair use” principle, a standard used by courts to determine the legality of unauthorized use of copyrighted works.

The MPA’s approach to AI reflects years of studios’ concerns over copyright protection, especially in the age of the internet. With AI, however, studios are advocating for flexibility. They believe that while strong copyright protection remains the industry’s backbone, there’s also a significant interest in developing AI tools that can support the creation of top-tier content.

In conclusion, as AI continues to permeate various sectors, the debate over its intersection with copyright laws is bound to intensify. While studios are currently advocating for the adequacy of existing laws, it remains to be seen how these stances might evolve as AI technologies become even more advanced and prevalent in the entertainment industry.


Livy AI: A Game-Changer for Studios

In the midst of these discussions on AI and copyright, there’s a growing recognition of the potential benefits AI platforms can bring to the entertainment industry. One such platform making waves is Livy AI, an AI-powered tool designed specifically for content creators, including screenwriters and studios.

Livy AI’s capabilities extend beyond mere content generation. It offers a suite of tools that can assist in script analysis, plot development, and character arc creation. For studios, this means a more streamlined pre-production process. By utilizing Livy AI, studios can identify potential plot holes, inconsistencies, or areas of improvement in scripts, ensuring a higher quality of content right from the start.

Moreover, the cost implications are significant. Traditional script development often involves multiple rounds of revisions, consultations, and sometimes even complete overhauls. With Livy AI, studios can potentially reduce these iterative processes, leading to substantial savings in both time and money. The platform’s ability to provide instant feedback and suggestions can expedite the scriptwriting process, allowing studios to produce content faster and at a fraction of the traditional cost.

Furthermore, Livy AI’s capabilities are not just limited to scriptwriting. The platform can also assist in post-production processes, such as editing, by providing insights based on data analytics. This can be particularly beneficial for studios looking to tailor their content for specific audiences or demographics.

In an industry where efficiency and cost-effectiveness are paramount, tools like Livy AI represent the future. As studios navigate the complex landscape of AI and copyright, integrating platforms like Livy AI might just be the key to staying ahead of the curve and producing top-tier content in a more efficient manner.

Jonathan Browne
Jonathan Brownehttps://livy.ai
Jonathan Browne is the CEO and Founder of Livy.AI

Table of contents

Read more

More News